Comparison · Updated May 2026
ZipRecruiter vs My Friendly Staff
ZipRecruiter syndicates your post across 100+ job sites and applies machine-learning matching, but small business owners report inconsistent quality and surprise pricing for hourly roles.
The short answer
Choose ZipRecruiter when: You're hiring for a salaried or specialized role where matching across a wide candidate pool matters — say, a manager-level position where you want a national-ish search.
Choose My Friendly Staff when: You're hiring local hourly workers (line cooks, baristas, stylists, retail clerks) where the best candidates live within 5 miles and respond to a sign in the window faster than a job board email.
Pricing
ZipRecruiter: starts ~$299/mo for one job slot (May 2026), with surprise upcharges for performance-based pricing. My Friendly Staff: $100/mo flat, unlimited jobs, no per-listing fees.
Side-by-side feature comparison
| Feature | My Friendly Staff | ZipRecruiter | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $100/mo flat, unlimited jobs | ~$299/mo starting, per-slot | MFS wins |
| Job distribution | Sign + branded link + Google Jobs (via schema) | Syndicates to 100+ sites | Competitor wins |
| AI matching | AI screens and ranks every applicant | AI matches resumes to your post | Tie |
| Phone-first applicants | Native — call the number on the sign | Web-only | MFS wins |
| Bilingual screening | Yes, native English + Spanish | Posting only | MFS wins |
| Best for | Local hourly hires | Salaried, regional/national searches | Tie |
Common questions about ZipRecruiter vs My Friendly Staff
Why is ZipRecruiter so expensive for small businesses?
ZipRecruiter's per-slot pricing model assumes you're hiring continuously across multiple roles. For a small business hiring 1–2 people per quarter, the math rarely works out — you pay $300/mo for slots you only use 25% of the time.
Can I cancel ZipRecruiter and use My Friendly Staff instead?
Yes. ZipRecruiter is month-to-month with no contract; you can cancel any time. MFS imports your active job descriptions during onboarding so you don't lose your screening questions.
Try My Friendly Staff free
$5 your first month, then $100/mo. Cancel anytime. Live in 10 minutes.
Get your hiring numberCompare other tools